ECDC and EMCDDA make the case for active case finding of communicable diseases in prison
What are the most (cost-) effective ways to prevent and control communicable diseases in prison settings? In their joint public health Guidance published today, ECDC and the European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction (EMCDDA), present the evidence on active case finding as a key measure to diagnose communicable diseases early. The two agencies advise to actively offer testing for hepatitis B, hepatitis C and HIV to all people in prison and to conduct universal testing for tuberculosis at prison entry.
The Guidance provides scientific advice on different options for active case finding among people in prison in order to diagnose a range of communicable diseases early. For this, ECDC and the EMCDDA systematically retrieved and assessed the evidence on the effectiveness of active case finding interventions for blood-borne viruses, sexually transmitted infections and tuberculosis in prison settings in the European Union and European Economic Area.
Interrupting transmission with test-and-treat approach
Compared to the general public, people in prison have a higher burden of communicable diseases such as hepatitis B (HBV), hepatitis C (HCV) and HIV, syphilis, gonorrhoea, chlamydia and tuberculosis (TB). This constitutes a health risk for those living, and working, in prison settings as well as for the general population, given that the majority of people in prisons return to their communities after a short period of incarceration (median length of detention in Europe is less than nine months).
The ECDC–EMCDDA Guidance is based on consultations with a panel of prison experts, and identifies the most (cost-) effective approaches with the aim to interrupt transmission in, and between, prison settings as well as the community, by first testing and then offering treatment to those infected.
Diagnosing infectious diseases in the prison population is challenged by several factors such as the silent nature of many chronic infections, particularly in early stages of infection, limited health literacy and reticent health-seeking behaviour. Suboptimal access to care in prison settings adds to the problem. According to the principle of equivalence of care, people in prison should enjoy an equivalent standard of care as in the community. Yet, their health needs tend to be greater.
Key conclusions: Active case finding in prison settings
- Actively offer testing for HBV, HCV, HIV to all people in prison.
- Evidence shows: pro-active provision leads to higher uptake; health promotion and peer education increase at least HIV testing uptake.
Sexually Transmitted Infections
- Several testing approaches may be considered, including risk-based, age-based or universal testing.
- Evidence shows: active testing offer leads to higher uptake than client-initiated testing.
- Actively offer universal provider-initiated testing for active TB at prison intake.
- Offer of latent TB testing may be considered, at least for individuals at high risk of disease progression, depending on local epidemiology and the availability of resources.
Accordingly, recent epidemiological data show that among people with a positive diagnostic test in prison, sizeable proportions were unaware of their status:
- 53% of those HBV positive were unaware of their infection;
- 44% of those with latent TB infection;
- 12% of those HCV positive;
- 3% of those who were HIV positive.
The high percentage of people in prison who are not aware of their health status in turn increases the risk for further transmission. Developing an accurate epidemiologic overview of infectious diseases in prison settings is therefore vital for public health and healthcare planning purposes.
Following on from the principles for HIV testing services outlined by the World Health Organization, the ECDC–EMCDDA Guidance provides the following seven principles as the foundation of active case finding approaches, both in prison settings and in the community:
- counselling (or communication),
- correct test results,
- connection to prevention, care, and treatment
- continuity of care postrelease and
- an overall supportive culture within the prison system
While there is no clear indication on the most effective timing and modality for active case finding of sexually transmitted infections, and different testing approaches (risk-based, age-based or universal testing) may all be used in prison settings, the existing evidence shows that an active STI testing offer leads to higher uptake than client-initiated testing.
ECDC and the EMCDDA welcome the efforts of European HIV-Hepatitis Testing Week to increase positive dialogue among those who might benefit from being tested and those who offer tests across Europe. The first Spring edition of European Testing Week is currently underway (18 to 25 May 2018).
Systematic review on active case finding of communicable diseases in prison settings
23 Nov 2017 - The objective of this report is to systematically review the evidence on active case finding in prison settings, with a focus on the European Union (EU) and the European Economic Area (EEA) region.
Systematic review on the diagnosis, treatment, care and prevention of tuberculosis in prison settings
30 May 2017 - The objective of this report is to systematically review data on the diagnosis, treatment, care and prevention of tuberculosis in prison settings, with a focus on the countries of the European Union and the European Economic Area.
Cost-effectiveness analysis of programmatic screening strategies for latent tuberculosis infection in the EU/EEA
23 Mar 2018 - The elimination of tuberculosis (TB) in Europe will require the management of latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) in key populations. Management of LTBI requires the identification and adequate treatment of infected people. It is currently unknown how screening and treatment of key populations should be best organised to have the highest impact with the available resources.